HomeScienceDo Osteoarthritis Treatments Actually...

Do Osteoarthritis Treatments Actually Work? New Study Questions Efficacy

Knee Pain Arthritis X ray

Osteoarthritis is a common degenerative joint disease that primarily affects the cartilage, the cushioning tissue between bones. It is characterized by the gradual breakdown of cartilage, leading to joint pain, stiffness, and limited mobility. Although it often occurs with age, factors such as genetics, obesity, and joint injuries can contribute to its development.

Recruiting osteoarthritis patients with a lot of pain to clinical studies, may give incorrect results if the researcher does account for the natural variation in pain that occurs. A research group from Lund University in Sweden is now drawing attention to the traps in clinical studies on osteoarthritis.

Osteoarthritis, a chronic joint disease, is growing more common. The incidence of this disease escalates with age, frequently leading to pain, compromised physical capability, and disability. As of today, roughly one in every four adults above the age of 45 in Sweden, approximately one million people, has sought medical attention for osteoarthritis.

Patients with osteoarthritis often undergo variations in their level of pain, with episodes of severe pain being interspersed with periods of less intense discomfort. This is a normal occurrence, however, it can pose a challenge for research on osteoarthritis treatments. Typically, researchers will select participants for their studies who are experiencing pain above a certain threshold, which can complicate the interpretation of results.

“People who have a lot of pain are likely to have less pain at a later measurement. This is called “regression to the mean”. Because of this phenomenon, measurements during follow-up will often show positive effects whether the treatment is effective or not”, says Martin Englund, professor of epidemiology at Lund University, and physician at the orthopedic clinic, Skåne University Hospital.

In a study, together with statistician and associate professor Aleksandra Turkiewicz, they estimated the magnitude of the improvement that arises from regression to the mean for a typical study in osteoarthritis. That is, the part of the “improvement” that is simply due to natural variation.

The study is based on data from a large population-based study in the United States of people with knee osteoarthritis. The researchers found that the phenomenon explained about 1 point improvement on a pain scale from 0 to 10 (no pain to worst pain imaginable).

“This represents a significant proportion of the reported improvement in many studies, especially considering that investigators often observe an average pain reduction of only 1 to 2.5 points in knee osteoarthritis patients,” says Martin Englund.

Much of the apparent treatment effect is just an illusion, according to the researchers. To determine whether a treatment is effective or not, there must be an adequate control group that receives a placebo, the study participants do not know what treatment they have received, and the treatment is randomly allocated. Therefore, for a treatment to be considered effective, it must produce better results than a placebo, and investigators need to take regression to the mean into account.

The study, which is now being published in the journal Lancet Rheumatology, is important for planning and interpreting results from research evaluating the efficacy of treatments for osteoarthritis pain.

“There is a great need for more effective treatments for osteoarthritis, which unfortunately means that the market opens up for several forms of treatments that incorrectly claim efficacy or exaggerate its size. Injections with platelet-rich plasma (PRP) are an example of a treatment with insufficiently proven efficacy, but also exercise in osteoarthritis is an example where the studies often lack a relevant control group and the effects on pain are often overstated”, concludes Martin Englund.

Reference: “Pain in clinical trials for knee osteoarthritis: estimation of regression to the mean” by Martin Englund and Aleksandra Turkiewicz, 21 April 2023, The Lancet Rheumatology.
DOI: 10.1016/S2665-9913(23)00090-5

- A word from our sponsors -

Most Popular

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More from Author

An Unprecedented 190% Quantum Efficiency – New Material Could Drastically Increase the Efficiency of Solar Panels

Lehigh University researchers have created a revolutionary solar cell material with...

Even Brief Secondhand Smoke Exposure Increases Risk of Dangerous Heart Rhythm Disorder

New research indicates that even minimal exposure to secondhand smoke increases...

Neuronal Crossroads: Decoding Brain Development

New research uncovers the developmental pathways of inhibitory neurons in the...

Quantum Control Unlocked: Creating Resistance-Free Electron Channels

New research demonstrates control over quantum states that could revolutionize energy...

- A word from our sponsors -

Read Now

An Unprecedented 190% Quantum Efficiency – New Material Could Drastically Increase the Efficiency of Solar Panels

Lehigh University researchers have created a revolutionary solar cell material with up to 190% external quantum efficiency, pushing beyond conventional efficiency limits and showing great promise for enhancing future solar energy systems. Further development is required for practical application, supported by a U.S. Department of Energy grant.It...

Even Brief Secondhand Smoke Exposure Increases Risk of Dangerous Heart Rhythm Disorder

New research indicates that even minimal exposure to secondhand smoke increases the risk of atrial fibrillation, a common heart rhythm disorder. The study, involving over 400,000 adults from the UK Biobank, found a progressive increase in risk with longer exposure durations, regardless of the environment. The findings...

Neuronal Crossroads: Decoding Brain Development

New research uncovers the developmental pathways of inhibitory neurons in the brain, highlighting the roles of proteins like MEIS2 and DLX5 in neuron differentiation and the potential link to neurodevelopmental disorders through genetic mutations. Credit: SciTechDaily.comStudy reveals how proteins direct nerve cell precursors to turn into specialized...